I February 6, 1975 / 301 'Ja wHY TNDIANS ARE HOMELESS lN THE| R HOMELAND CAROL EHRLICH WRITES ON MEN'S LIBERATION ' oeprÑse SPENDTNG AND rHE ECONOMY"(P4BI,l!!1. __, ptus A HILARIOUS TALE OF MADNESS lN THE MILITARY qEACE AND FREEDOM THR,U NONWOL?NT ACTION 9OI?? l1ü S.!,H 0f\¡V13^l-tf ìt8 NÐfiNrl3 IOGUü1r"ÌJ U ^ü-t8J 0I*ç¿ 'rZ€,r7. 3H I Blv¡ L.l(¡ Tlhn ÞoP.ry röi { 0 fr h (* rv fì 1.0.Sh¡rty liriTo.¡lrtoo l(yi¡ lldtldt Kri¡ Hrtr¡lt I are known to but q,f'erv of the collective mcml¡e¡s. Wo rvish the working committee every s_uccessr but at present niany of us are d,ubious as to its worth and future. Thu,s, though members of the collective may wish to pàrtake of the latest.movement oûering, of us do not so desire,.and, let me aflirm once again, Black Rose is not in any way a part of this or any other wofking committcc or fþderation. m.ost úr,î#TTr:îss ' I believe the wo¡ld food crisisto bè one of the nonviolent radical left. With ou¡ emÞhas¡s on what Finnerty IWtN, l1llT t74l calls creative our lives and our goals. Fern's daily life was working tbr peace in various spheres. She was to have bèen the l¡rst student to complete the peace studies plogram she put togethe¡ at New College. She had bec¡l involved in trying to couñter the militarism in high schools and in the campaign against the B-l boinbe¡. Seemingly evêryone who knew her was greatly aft'ected by her. She was the most loving person i hâve ever knowrr,¡urely,an example of \Mhat people mirst bê like ,,afte¡ the,revolution" if we a¡e to'have effected real, lasting change in the society. t[ yott unl go on any longer . take the hond þel! by your brother every vlctory brÍngs anoiher Carry Ít on; cany it on Donations may be made.i¡ Fern's memory to tho Ame¡ican F¡iends Se¡vice Committee, 160 North 15 St.,.philadelþhia, Wllen PA rero2' the l2l26l7a --.fr,T:,:l,t:il issue of WIN contained a let ter from Judith Málina on an anarchist conference held in Cambridge. I cannot vouch' for the àccuracy of the report as a whole, but it did.contain one er¡or that is greatly disturbiri!. Judith wrote that the cõ¡ference was hosted by Btàok Rose. This is totally false, Black Rosè nèver agreed to'host anything, though some members of the collective attended parts of the conference, lV^e are not now, and never have been a.part of any anarchist,conferences or working cammittees.or whaüevei as a collêctive bodf, It iinportant th¿t this be emphasized publicly, as apparently, some membèrs of is the working committee persist in. the falsehood that Black Rose is part.of their coterie. A recent communication from one Mer¡il Moss lists two people in Camb¡idge as a¡ea contacts for the working committee under.the name of Biack Rose who have never been a part ofBlack Rose and who , Adam FTnnerty who obviously tinow what ' they. are talking about. I am just starting oqt in radical nonvioíence and would ai preciate concrete facts, tips, etc, about how best to go about a struggle against world hunger. WIN! _R.S. WILLIS Boulder, Colo. . It is tho ad reading: "Don't die without will. l{ill forms plus attorney's instructions-$2 refundable." There follow a name a and, address, The validity of wills is controlled by separate laws in all 50 states. No single will form is valid in all states, In fact, the will form which the Maryland.gentleman advertises rhay no! even be valid in Maryland. Unhappily, unless a will writer has legal training, about his only recourse is to obtain the services of a lawyer.-JOE FELMET lVinston-Salem, NC with supposed "nonviolent revolutiona¡ies" is that they are often more "nonviolent" than "revolutionary''; that is; they are more con cerned with their "moral purity" than with actually doing what has to be done to overturn the violent system which is capitalisrq Lance Bélville's review of The Mother and The Great AÍr Robbery in yóur t2l26l7 4 issue has given me another instance, another example The two plays were performed here in Washington, and though I did not see the latter ong the responæ la The Mother wæ incredible. Not only was it an inspiration and a lift to me for days but I heard of no one who had seen it-including some "noÞ of those of continued capitatiet rule that the rulers always refer to the "complex" natu¡e of events, always: just happen to be the only ones who could "solve" the problems facing the country. That is not true. The only "complexity" they face is the.complex tæk of holding back the æpirations of the world's people a¡ they become aware of the simple reality that,the reason for the bulk of thei¡ prob lems iests in one central fact tho owiership of the resources, the factories, the banks, the governmentq indeed, the w'irrld, by a tiny minority ofcapitalists. If that problem we¡e solved the key would be found to solve the remainde¡ of the world's problemg æzuming that avision of a just, ogalitarian and clæsless society was constantly st¡uegled for, æsuming that we tried to bring that reality down to earth and live our lives and æt in ways which reflected that goal. Things are complex only when those supposed rer¡olutionaries are divorced from the livee of those.who are most oppre¡sed,1 by capitalism and thus most open to ând in need of rerrolutionary ch'ange-Third.lVorld people, working people, women. Ifthe connections to their lives are deep, if the movement is fhmly rooted in their hopes and dreams, their frustrations and difrcultieg then the simple irclution can be found: the rising of us all, the destruction of the power of the capitalist state, the building . to the- hearts ofþeop¡e-to give up what theydon't need. perhaps evin Saiyagraha. lVe need more a¡ticles from people fike The one problem I harre always had am certain that the response people in New York-with.a few ux."oiioi* obviousry including Mr. Bélvilre*¡,rd in;i;¡: ¡ng even a reviewe¡ for the IfI/ fi¿¡"r *no wlote a favorable revi'ew of it, was the s11e. Whv then did Mr. Belville w¡ite as hé -' did, and why did wIN print his ¡eviewiobviously, ¡ don,t kriow. But I believe a clue. i! Biven in one of his puagraphs" He says "The wo¡ld in which Brecht sets his play is not our world and probably hasn't been únce the Civil War. Ti¡e issues in Mother and Robbery at heart the same, but the fal¡ric in which B¡echt confronts these. issuesjs so-hopelessly simple that I sugge$ts." It is a-major defense non-threatening campaign against the lbrces of greed, ignorance, bad fortune, and wrong priorities that aüow hunger and death to hold sway. Did I say campãign? Maybe wrr would be a móre honest liord to use. I personally desire this wa¡ to be waged by nonviolent but socialistic means. What I mean is this: the socializatíon of agriculture and fuels.in the United Staies, coupled with constant and varied appeals I am an avid reader of People's Bulletin Board. Infer¡ing that others are, I want to' point out an ad unde¡ "Se¡vices" that may in fact be a disse¡vice. I ¡ tion, the non-existence of equal justice) are all necessary tbr the pe¡petuation of US . could not identify with the solution he simplicity we can presentä nonviolènt, victim of one man's jealousy and anger, and of a society's acceptancc of violence and the Ame¡ican aflection lbr fìre arms. He¡ dcath has fbrced many of us to ré-examine tremendously impressed. îe if not the mâjor task of I know liêrn Newman's.fìiends will be sorry to hear ol hcr death lll30l74. She was the violent" types-who had not al$q beçn imperialism. Of ,e.qual necessity to the ruling'class is the separation and division of the people of this couñtry, the same people' to whom you offer youf services. It is to this:poinf that l,wish to"speak. In your statement yor¡.spoke of the 70,000 draft resisters, deserters, and ribjectors, all of whoril are indeed sufferióg an injustice. But what ofthe hundreds of thousands of people in the samb categories, about which thþ government has not"even acknowledged (those underground)ïOf equal iniportance (if not.more), what of the estimated 570,000 yeterans with less than hoirorable discharges? We cannot aÊ ford to separate the forms of resistanóe to the war that evolved ovê¡ the years of anti' . our common struggle.'Ëverjr opportunity must-be seized and utilized to advance this anallsis. We cannot allow the government to structure the lbrms of our dissent. In an otherwise beautitïl and meaningf ul stqtement, you have täiled to do this, ' 'Tinally, I feel, and I am sure the other B¡othe¡s and Sisters in resistanêe f'eel thàt you ¡eed no pardôn for reaching your deciiúon in the time that it took you, We get stronger every day ãnd you .Éro,w and are certainly not the la$t. I speak as one who has gone th¡u similar crises, ãs I did not reach my decision to resist the dratt until aftql I had gone thru much personal struggle. _ With or without God, the people UniIõd_ use' .' ";iå?,îitSä Dear Dlvight Ernest, I was inspired by your letter.io the S.S.S. pubtisþed in IVIN, t2llLl74.'|oa ay parently have done serious t\inking and studying on the system of cohscrip-tion and all that such a-repressive Systón ¡e¡> resents and serves in this socieiy. However I believe Jhat there is still roorn for growth and development in you¡ anaþsis, The.evils Jhat you desc¡ib,àd (militarism, domestic and foreign. economic exoloitation, covert and overt military intirven. . ' '\ CaqNever BE Defeated. ,T war struggle, Over half of those bad dischæges were issued to third wo¡ld people-an extremely disproport'ionate number. Ariyone with a bad discharge has been punishêd for the "crime" of resisting the oppression and racis:m of the military. Therefore; when we speak of amnesty and/or the lack of justice, we must include all types of resistance which certainly makes 70,000 people look small by comparison, Tq focus only on the people. that the government recognizes, allows the government to perpetuate the lie . that ¡esistance to the war involves only a relatively small number of "white middle class" dr¿ft evade¡s. We only reinforce the racist and class bias of American society by distinguishing "political" and "mor¿I" acts from "c¡iminal acts." Let us nòt do the work of the government by.separating .. ourselves fròm our comrades-yóur'brothe¡s number far more than 70,000. This ¿ll may.be academic since yotr might already be aware of these realities. However the essence of my criticism is that we must always communicate, educate, and "! organize around the importance of unity in -_ -BOB MACFARLANE .,. poughkeepsie¡ , -. f. rvry-{r Ny Februäry 6,1975'lVol. Xl, Number 4 4. Why lndians Are Homeless in Their Homeland I Pgt Porty 8. The Reluctant Patriarchs Carol Ehrlich complainr tl,ettgg, t?ls !.7.!1, about WIN publishing so mäiy a;aicidò about gays and what he calls "their whines and complaints" is proof positive that no: i,¡ matter how liberal one may purport to be, a screeching halt is called to liberal philos ophy on the part of some when gay life Styles are explored in \üIN and other conscionable journals of radical opiníon, lVhat F, Tysen should realize is that, basically, wê are persons before we-aré.- -' male or female or gay, and each and everyone of us has all sexual drives built into our psychic systems, It is social conditioning that prompts sexual preferences, and not simply genitalia. For genltalia alone do not dictate what practices of sexuality should predominate ryithin given cultures, American and otheruiise. WIN is to be roundly thanked for þelp ing gays and other oppressed groups get thei¡ collective shit together. .J.J. KAUFMANN Honolulu, Hawaii 12. A Further Ntote on lntl4tion and the Military Budget I Edword S.'Hermon t þ 14. Your Defense Dollars at Work 1 7. Changes 20. Reviews Cover: Photo from Human Love in Að- tion/LNS. Drawings from the'1972 calendar of the Taller Grafico de la Cooperativa Agricolo del Pueblo de Tierra Amarillo, in New MexícÒ. STAFF Maris Cakars . Susan Cakars. Chuck Fager , Mary Mayo. Susan Pines. Fred Rosen t;'l Mumay R"osenblith . MarthaThomases . ,. i UNINDICTED CO.CONSPIRATORS of socialisn My gues is that Mr. SslviUe's poor rq view came from his bei¡rg more "nonviolènt" than rerrolutionary; from his ireing divorcad from the tlay-today struggles. of the poor æ he struggled to become a mot'e "nonviolent" person That kind of"nonviolence" none óf uscan ,," i, i" J? Barry. Lance Belvllle . Jerry Coffln Lynne Coffln . Ann Davldon , D¡ana Davles Ruth D€ar . Ralph Dlcla. Br¡an Doherty I Seth Foldy "Jim Forest. L€ah Frltz. Larry Gara Nell Haworth rEd Hedemann. Grace Hedemann Karla J.ay. Marty Jezer. Bocky John'on Nancy Jöhnson'.Paul Johnson .Alllson Karpel . Cralg Karpel iJoñh Kyper , Ellot Llnzer' Jackson Mac Low" Dav¡d McReynolds i..' David Morrls úMark Morrls.çJlm Peck Tad Rlchards. lgal Roodehko. Nancy Roson..... ' Jan LTFETT ME SUBSCRIPTIONS-$ 1 00 Here's a way to insure that you'll never again be bothered by those would-be-humorous WIN reneìval announcements and at the same time make a substant¡al ccimm¡ttment to the ca'use of nonviolent social change by supporting WIN Magazine. Such a demonstration of faith in WIN at this time would mean far more than year after year of renewals. Please consider helping out ¡n th¡s wâ!: -WlN . t.:..,..-. ¡r..,., Ed Sanders.Wendy Schwartz. Art Waskow ' ., Allen Young. Beverly,Woodwård Box 547:lRifton / New York 12471 Telephone:91+339-4585 . WIN is publ¡stled Weskly exc€pt for the flßt two weeks ln January, znd week ln May, last 4 weeks in August, and the last w€ek ln October by th€ WIN Publishlng Emplre wlth the support of the War Res¡sters L€ague. Subs¡rlpuons are p9r year. Second class pe6tago at Nsw .$.1!0q York, t\Y 1OO01. Indlvlduat wrlt6is are rêsponsible for oplnions o(pressed and accuracy of facts glven. SorrlFmanuscrlpts cannot' bá returned unless accompanled by a self-addres$d stampêd onv6lope. Prlnt€d ¡n U.S.A. 2 WrN wrN 3 IITHY INDIANS ARE HOMELESS for continued occupancy because various design and construction deficiencies resulted in cracked or bowed basement walls." PAT PORTER IN THEIRHOMELAND It ¡ Little ment of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), plans were laid in Washington'with little or no lndian 'rinput or control over construction work, and the rcsults have often been dismal. ln fábt, of the 232 nerr or renovated houses on 22 reservations surveyed by" GAO in 1971, construction deficiencies were found in 187 (80%) and repair costs were running as high as $3,500 'Somefor some houses. tribes filed suit against government-approved construction companies because of the poor housing bu¡lt. The Housing Authority of Laguna Pueblo in New Mexico filed suit in 1972 against the Building 'Contractors, lnc. for constructibn deficiencies ln i59 new homes. HUD approved the finished housing and the company refused to correct the deficiencies; The Ropebud Sìoux Housing Authority also considered a sirnilar.suit against the Eaily Redwood'Gbmpany, the contractor for the "Sioux 400" homes. HUD offered ,to contribute $F00,000 to fix up tlfe homes although' over $3.5 milliòn was needed, according to the South Dakota Todd County Tribune of May 4,1972. Government policy is to givè preference to tribal members when hiring and to tribal construction companies when giving contracts but because of lack of. financial resources. few lndians have been trained in constructiòn skillô'and there are only seven tribal con- progess has beeri.made in improvinglndian housing. ln 1969, 50,000 new units were needed, but now, because of increased population and constant deterioration of homes, 46,556 are nçeded. This. includes units required for people wäñting to.return to reservations and families currently living with other . families and having no homes of their own. Repaírs are needed for 24,000 homes. According to the US Public Health Service, respon- . t INDIAN . LANDS BEFORE I^THITES INVADED,.. È""' Cree¡ River Perce Klamath t Modoc .1 I Paiutê ¡ at end I Ottowa low¡ Alebrme Coushett6l .(Ù Res. sible for construction of most reservation sanitary and water facilities, 7O% of the lndian people must still haul drinking water, often from distant plaçes; 75% get water from potentially polluted sources. 77%have inadequate sanitary facilities, or.none at all. On the vast Navajo Reservation, the size of West Virginia, only 22% of the homes have running water compared to 900/o of the US homes in general. It is no wonder there is such an enormous gap between the health of lndians and that of other Ameri. cans. lndians are plagued with infectious diseases such as bacillary dysentary, which in 1972 occurred 49.6 times more among lndians tþan the general , population; the rate for infectjous hepatitis was.10.7 times gre4ter than the general population. The death rate for infaqts from one month through eleven months was.double that of the comparable age group in the general population. lnnumerabíe examples of poor lndiån housing can be cited. A 1970 Look magazine reported that the Cocopahs, a small tribe in southwestern Arizona, were living in mud, twig, and cardboard huts. This situation exists despite the fact that all who are officially enrolled on the tribal list have been eligible for federal assistance; as of 1971, however, only 85 of the proud people had done so. Now, through government efforts 500 aîe enrolled, but màny others still are not. Today, 410/o of the Cocopah families live in substandard dwellings or are living with other families and need homes of their own. Although some San Carlos Apache families of Arizona have moved into new three-bedroom homes, 'there are still 300-400 families in small shacks wiih dirt floors and inadequate sanitary faciìities, and little protection from bitter cold winters. 77% of the housing is substandard. On the Sioux Pine Ridge Reservation in South Dakota, where the Wounded Knee take-over occurred in'1973,610/o of the families live in substaçrdard houses or need homes of their own. There have been new houses built at Pi¡e Ridge, yet a General Accounting Office report of 1971 said those homes "may have to be condemned as unsafe Unakalelt lnd. Res. , INDIAN Pot Porter wos o reporter for Wassaia, an lndian newspaper published in San Frønc¡sco, ond ìs currently working with the Coalltion of Eastern Native Ameri- ? a LANDS TODAY cons. is evident that whcn housing had been provided. by the Bureau of lndian Affairs (BlA), and the Depart- Nearly one million American lndl ans-the nation's poorest citizens-arè accustomed to having, r¡¡ost of their hôusing needs ígnored by th'e government. For instance, althou!h public housing legislation was passed'in 1937, the government did not decidê that tribes were eligible for public housing until 1961. And even now, public housing serves low and middle income farnilies but unemployed.¡nd othel very poor I ndians cannot qualify. i ,' stiuctioir companies. I There is also evidence of misuse of funds appropriated for lndian housing. On the California Hoopa Reservation after floods in "1964 carried away lndian homes, Congress appropriated $1.9 million for housing. Less than $500,000 was actualiy spent on housing and land purchase. lt is still unclear where the remainder was spent although William Finale, who was the BIA . area director, made his records available for perusäl; these records, however, could not account for $1,417,000 according to the New York Times of Sept. 14, 1969. lndians at Hoopa filed suit challenging the Bureau's.use of funds. ln the houses built at Hoopa, floors were unsteady, roofs leakeC, bedrooms lacked doors, and tþe power line was 19 miles away with no connection to the homes which were wired with electric lights. The homes were to be heated with petroleum gas, which in 1964 cost'$80 a month, far too expensive for most families. Because firewood was readily available'for fuel, some homes had chimney fixlures installed for' wood burning stoves, but most'did'not and some of , ' the poorest fãmilies broke out windows and vented stove pipes through them. While some tribes have gotten short-changed, tribes with more political clout have managed to make profits from their housing projects. On the scenic welltimbered Mescalero Reservation in southern New Mexico, low-rent homes built 12 years ago were fall,ing apart by 1972 because of faulty construction and over-crowded living conditions and were scheduled for demolition and replacement. According to a HEW official in the Native American Affairs offce, "The government spent $29,000 for each house constructed, but since the actual cost was only about $20,000, the ¡:.' tribe made a profit of $9,000." Another problem is that the góvernment has re-fused to allow tribes to decide for themselves how to meet their housing needs. Typical low-income govern- fnd. Res. 4 WtN _LNS wrN 5 for an increase of $260 million for public housing in Ihe "1974 housing act in order to help HUD meet such mcnt housing standards have bcen modelcd aftcr those t¡f middlc-American surburban dwcllings. Thcy were supposed to bc su¡tablc t